Maintaining the body's water balance is crucial for function and survival in all animals. Humidity conditions vary between different habitats and greatly affect an animal's evaporative water loss (EWL). Species inhabiting arid regions have adaptions to minimize water loss, which those adapted to life in humid regions may lack. Therefore, the physiology of species from different habitats could respond differentially to acute exposure to dry conditions. We measured the EWL and resting metabolic rates (RMRs) of 12 Israeli squamate species, from either mesic or xeric habitats, spanning four orders of magnitude in size. We treated the animals to dry and humid air simulating natural conditions (vapor pressure deficits 3 and 1 kPa, respectively) at an ecologically relevant temperature of 25 degrees C. EWL rates were higher in dry air, and the effect was stronger in mesic species. EWL of mesic species in humid air is similar to EWL of xeric species in dry air, indicating similar EWL when tested under settings that match each species' natural conditions. In dry air, the RMR of small-bodied (<5 g) mesic species increased, whereas those of some small-bodied xeric species decreased. Small mesic species might be displaying stress from unnaturally dry conditions, whereas small xeric species possibly display an adaptation to minimize EWL by lowering RMR, thereby respiration rates. Physiological measurements are usually taken in dry air, and our results suggest previous experiments may contain a methodological bias. Future ecophysiological research needs to consider ambient humidity, by either varying experimental humidity to match natural conditions, or considering possible effects of humidity during analysis and interpretation of experiments and models.