Long-term restoration practices have been often reported to enhance soil organic carbon (SOC) and nitrogen (N) stocks in grassland ecosystems. However, there is a limited understanding of how vegetation restoration affects SOC and N stocks at different soil depths over short timescales in semi-arid grassland of North China. To address this problem, we conducted a field study to investigate the effects of plant properties on the SOC and N stock changes during a nine-year period of grassland restoration practices (natural recovery; shallow ploughing; harrowing) in a semi-arid grassland of North China. The results revealed that three restoration practices had a positive contribution to SOC and N stocks following nine years of recovery, however, the rates of SOC and N stock changes under mechanical disturbance were lower across the 0-60 cm soil depth when compared with the natural recovery. The biomass of litter, roots, and dominant plant species were the major factors contributing to SOC and N stock changes. Our findings from the nine-year restoration experiment suggested that short-duration natural recovery is likely to be a beneficial strategy for the restoration of both the plant community and the soil nutrients. Our findings elucidate the regulatory mechanisms of dominant plant species on SOC and N stock changes following revegetation and suggest that the overcompensatory growth of dominant species should be fully considered in grassland restoration.